For many contractors, the end of the policy year brings a premium audit. The carrier compares your original estimates with what actually happened, and the difference becomes a bill or a refund. A workers comp audit can catch a contractor off guard when the business has grown, hired help, or changed the work it does. Many of the issues that drive the result can still be addressed before the year closes with a review of your contractor insurance program.
Consider a Pennsylvania remodeling contractor that set its payroll estimate when the policy started. Over the year, the business grew well past that estimate and used three 1099 subcontractors who never provided certificates of insurance.
At audit, the carrier adds the extra payroll. It also charges the uninsured subs’ costs at the contractor’s own class rates, on both the workers comp and the general liability policy. In the end, the contractor owes an additional $38,000 in premium due in 30 days, plus a higher deposit on the renewal.
The Audit Risks Contractors Overlook
Several gaps can build up during the year without anyone noticing. Review these risks before your policy year ends:
- Underestimated payroll or gross receipts. The estimate set at inception no longer matches the business.
- Uninsured or underinsured subcontractors. At audit, their costs can be charged back as if they were your employees.
- Wrong class codes. Field and clerical splits, or trade classifications, may not match the work being done.
- Overtime not separated in payroll records. When the premium portion of overtime is not broken out, rated payroll goes up.
- Expired subcontractor certificates. If a certificate lapses midyear and nobody tracks it, the audit may treat that sub as uninsured.
- Owner and officer elections. Inclusion or exclusion choices may no longer reflect who works in the field.
- Ignored audit requests. Not responding can lead to an estimated audit and possible cancellation.
Coverages Every Contractor Should Review Before a Workers Comp Audit
An audit does not change what your policies cover, but it does show whether they were set up for the way you work. Check these pieces of your contractor insurance program.
Workers Compensation classified for the work you perform. This coverage is designed to protect employees who are injured on the job. Class codes should match the work your crews perform, with field and clerical payroll split correctly. For growing crews, ask whether a pay-as-you-go option is available, since it ties premium to actual payroll and can reduce audit swings.
General Liability rated on the right basis. This policy addresses injuries and property damage to others. Depending on the policy, it may be rated on payroll, gross receipts, or subcontracted cost. Confirm that the rating basis and your estimate reflect how the business operates today.
Subcontractor insurance requirements. Before the first payment, collect proof that each sub carries general liability and workers comp. Where required, your business should also be named as an additional insured. Without that proof, the audit may treat the sub’s cost as your own exposure.
Commercial Umbrella. An umbrella adds limits above your underlying policies. Because it is often rated off those underlying exposures, audit changes can ripple into the umbrella as well.
The Common Mistake: Treating the Audit as Paperwork
A contractor who treats the workers comp audit as the carrier’s paperwork is overlooking a cash-flow event the business can control. Many five-figure audit bills trace back to two fixable issues. One is a payroll estimate nobody updated midyear. The other is subcontractor certificates nobody collected.
When the audit arrives, both problems are already on the books. Addressing them before the policy year closes helps keep the final number closer to what you expected.
What to Do Before Your Policy Year Closes
Ahead of your workers comp audit, every contractor should set aside time to review these points:
- Do a payroll true-up now. If your policy renews January 1, use the fourth quarter to compare actual payroll to the original estimate and update it with your broker.
- Review your class codes. Make sure each employee is classified for the work they perform.
- Put a certificate process in place. Have someone other than the owner, such as an office manager or bookkeeper, run it. The rule is simple: no certificate, no payment.
- Consider pay-as-you-go for growing crews. Reporting payroll as you go can keep the audit from becoming a surprise.
MPL Risk can go over payroll, class codes, and subcontractor certificates with any contractor before the workers comp audit, so the likely result is clear before the auditor arrives. If something looks wrong, there is still time to question it. You can learn more on our Workers Compensation Insurance page and our Contractor Insurance page.
Protect Your Cash Flow Before the Audit
The audit will reflect everything that changed since the policy started. A short review now helps a contractor go into the workers comp audit knowing what to expect. That can protect both cash flow and the renewal. MPL Risk works with contractors across Pennsylvania and New Jersey to keep their contractor insurance in line with how the business runs.
Is your policy year ending? Have MPL Risk review your coverage before the auditor calls. Please reach out for a quote by contacting us online, or call (267) 888-4790.


